No announcement yet.

Caregiver's payment claim back in Court


  • Caregiver's payment claim back in Court

    A mother who successfully won the right to be paid for caring for her disabled son is back in court seeking compensation for decades of work and damages for "humiliation".

    Margaret Spencer and her son Paul, aged in his late 40s, were back at the High Court at Auckland on Monday after the Court of Appeal last year rejected a Ministry of Health appeal against a ruling that Spencer be paid for caring for Paul.

    Spencer has been caring for her son, who has Down syndrome, for the past 25 years but it wasn't until 2013 that the Ministry of Health was forced to accept an application from her to be paid for her work, following a Human Rights Review Tribunal and High Court decision that ruled family members should be paid for caregiving.

    At the time the High Court found the Ministry had acted unlawfully by refusing to consider her application, upholding a previous Human Rights Review Tribunal decision that ruled the family had been discriminated against.

    The ruling also paved the way for Spencer to seek damages for the years she had worked without pay, and should she be successful in her bid it could pave the way for others to do the same.

    The bid for compensation was launched on Monday in a civil hearing set down for four days at the High Court. Spencer's long-time lawyer James Farmer QC is arguing for the claim on her behalf, however there is not yet a dollar figure attached to the bid, counsel said.

    He told Justice Patrick Keane that Spencer had suffered "humiliation" in her attempts to claw back payment from the Ministry who he said had passed Spencer around "from one department to another".

    "She's really been treated in a way that is a very undignified manner," Farmer said. "She continues to be discriminated against because she is a family member."He argued that the salary Spencer should receive should at least be "analogous" to specialist support services, while the Ministry believed it should be assessed by the specific tasks she completed, excluding supervision, with a starting rate of minimum wage.

    Farmer said this was at odds with the fact that if Spencer decided she could no longer care for Paul, he would be placed in a residential care unit where support workers would be paid for round-the-clock care including supervision.
    Spencer would later give evidence about her son's disability, which required constant supervision due to his inability to make decisions for himself, Farmer said.

    Spencer had taken an active role in his care, he said. "Because of her devotion to seeking to make the best quality of life he can have, she has encouraged and assisted him to develop activities and skills."
    Spencer first began her fight for the right to receive payment about 13 years ago and during that time nasty emails had been found to be exchanged between government staff comparing Paul to a "tatty teddy bear".

    During one hearing Farmer read out examples of the emails, including one between Ministry of Social Development staff following a hearing where Spencer lost the right to a benefit.
    "She really laid the sympathy vote right on, dragging poor Paul around like a tatty teddy bear, telling the committee what a martyr she was," the email said.

    Credit; Stuff
    Attached Files
      Posting comments is disabled.

    Latest Articles


    • Judge Goddard refuses to answer MPs' questions
      by admin
      The former New Zealand judge who headed a UK inquiry into child sexual abuse has said she will not appear before British MPs to answer questions about her time in charge. Dame Lowell Goddard said for her to be summoned would compromise the inquiry's "independence and integrity". She also hit out at "malicious, defamatory attacks" by the British media and said she was disappointed the government had not defended her. British MPs have asked the former head of the child sex abuse inquiry to expl...
      11-11-2016, 11:47 AM
    • Judge Lowell Goddard's epic fail
      by admin
      Dame Lowell Goddard, the New Zealand judge who resigned last week as chair of the 100 million (N$183.5m) Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA), did not leave her post voluntarily but was effectively fired. Dame Lowell, appointed by then-Home Secretary Theresa May just over a year ago, had already lost the confidence of senior staff and members of the inquiry panel, according to two well-placed legal sources. The Home Office has denied she was sacked, according to reports. After she ...
      09-08-2016, 10:07 AM
    • Sir Ngatata Love's lawyer claims agreement had no impact on Trust
      by admin
      Sir Ngatata Love's lawyer Colin Carruthers QC says the Serious Fraud Office (SFO) theory against his client is wrong, with a key agreement placing no financial cost on the Wellington Tenths Trust. The former leading Treaty of Waitangi negotiator and academic is on trial in the High Court at Wellington, accused of obtaining funds by deception, or alternatively of obtaining a secret commission.The charges relate to allegations that Love showed favour to Auckland property developer Redwood, and ...
      05-08-2016, 01:44 PM
    • Transport boss pleads guilty to corruption charges
      by admin
      The Serious Fraud Office says the guilty plea yesterday by an Auckland Council manager to corruption charges shows the dangers in not questioning a culture of gratuities. Barrie Kenneth James George, 69, this morning at the High Court at Auckland pleaded guilty to two charges of accepting bribes as a public official when he took gifts worth $103,580 between 2005 and 2012. The gifts included cash, and lavish overseas holidays for George and his family. SFO Director, Julie Read welcomed the guilty plea...
      04-08-2016, 09:40 AM
    • Identities of corrupt JP's stay secret
      by admin
      The identities of Justices of the Peace disciplined for incompetence, making false allegations or misusing their title for personal gain are being kept secret by the Ministry of Justice.In the case of the above JP Denis Selwyn Callesen of Keri Keri, the Crown Law Office even halted a private prosecution against Mr Callessen after evidence emerged that Mr Callessen and his former secretary Robin Morris had perverted the course of justice.

      The Ministry believes the privacy of...
      23-07-2016, 11:35 AM
    • Government funded escape artist Philip Smith found guilty
      by admin
      The murderer who embarrassed New Zealand law and border authorities by flying to Brazil while on temporary release from prison has been convicted for the audacious escape. Charges of escaping lawful custody and making a false statement to renew a passport have been added to Phillip John Smith's lengthy criminal record, along with murder, child sex abuse, kidnapping, tax fraud and arson. In an unusual legal procedure, a jury was chosen at the Auckland District Court today and the judge immedia...
      22-07-2016, 01:05 PM